Open quarterback competition good, not bad

The wildcard in the open competition is incoming freshman P.J. Walker.
TFF welcomes Chris
Coyer, 1/14/2009

As former Giants’ coach Bill Parcells once blabbed, “that’s a good thing, not a bad thing” was the reaction I had when Matt Rhule announced an open quarterback competition going into this spring’s Temple football practice.
I like competition.
Really, he is not going to say: “I don’t care what any of these guys do, I’ve already decided.” That’s not good coaching business.
That’s the position former head coach Steve Addazio maintained two days before he went off to become head coach at Boston College. The first thing he said was that there was going to be an open quarterback competition. The second thing he said was that “this offseason is going to be no box of chocolates.” The third thing he said was “I’m outta here like Vladimir.” All in a matter of 48 hours.
If Connor Reilly beats out the field and becomes Temple’s starter on Aug. 31 against Notre Dame, every Temple football fan, coach and player is better off.
The same can be said of the other five quarterbacks who figure to be in the mix.
Because with the possible exception of when Adam DiMichele dined alone, Temple’s quarterbacking training room dinner table is more talented than any in the Golden/Addazio/Rhule Era.
If you beat out those guys, then you have something.
That said, I like John Madden’s quote better: “If you have more than one quarterback, you don’t have any.”
My guess is that Rhule will settle on one quarterback by Notre Dame and stick with him and that quarterback will be Chris Coyer.
There are a few reasons for that:

  • Coyer is the ONLY quarterback in the last 30 years to win a bowl game for Temple;
  • Coyer was recruited by Rhule;
  • Coyer was about to receive a scholarship offer from Ohio State and showed his loyalty to Rhule and the Owls by telling them thanks but no thanks;
  • Coyer replaced starter Chester Stewart in the Ohio game and threw for three touchdowns and over 300 yards passing and, oh by the way, added 184 yards on the ground;
  • Coyer played with a broken hand last year, taking one for the team;
  • Coyer was additionally handicapped by a run-first, second- and too-many-times third-approach by Daz;
  • Coyer can both throw and run equally effectively, a real plus in the days of the modern spread offense;
  • Coyer, without a broken hand two years, ago was UNBEATEN in games he started;
  • Coyer’s co-offensive coordinator during that unbeaten streak: Matt Rhule.

The wildcard in all of this is not necessarily Reilly but P.J. Walker. In a perfect world, you redshirt Walker and have him sponge all there is to know from Coyer, Rhule and graduate assistant DiMichele.
All of these facts are rattling around in Rhule’s brain right now and probably will continue to rattle until Aug. 31.
When the facts stop and the reasoning starts, unless Coyer completely comes apart (and we hear he’s having a good spring, too), Coyer will be under center.
After all, Rhule and Coyer have been an unbeatable combination in the past and there’s no reason to think that success can’t continue in their final year together.


5 thoughts on “Open quarterback competition good, not bad

  1. who recruited Juice out of HS, and how did he wind up at Temple? The scouting report on Temple QBs is weak arm strength and inaccurate beyond 10 yards…, this new pro spread should be changed to pro set west coast passing game via roll outs, passes to half backs, and crossing patterns…, our talent behind center is not capable of anything else…., I've watched film on PJ and he has two bad things in common with all other Temple QBs – poor throwing mechanics and no hope at being an NFL QB…., we have put more than our fair share of players in the NFL the last six years but zero QBs…., regardless of style and O system, all top15 teams share one thing in common which is pro worthy talent at QB….,

  2. I think you are wrong about P.J. He had big-time schools coming after him after he committed to Temple (Michigan, Virginia Tech, Florida State) and he turned them away.As far as Coyer, please replay the Ohio game. He threw a GREAT deep touchdown perfectly over the shoulder to Streater, a bullet down the middle for a TD to Deon Miller and another wonderful fade pass down the sideline to Joey Jones for six more. All delivered in stride over the shoulder.Those weren't flukes.

  3. we'll see…., are we going after the Pitt RB Shell?

  4. Not a bad idea, KD. Montel Harris redux?I would do it, Daz would do it.Don't know if MR is me or Daz.Don't like throwing all my eggs in the Zaire Williams' basket, which he appears to be doing and Jamie Gilmore has yet to prove he's anything more than a Matt Brown change-of-pace back.I'd put Herbin back there as Brown but MR for some reason likes Herbin as a slot and Gilmore in the Brown role.

  5. As far as Juice out of high school, Temple did not recruit him. Only after Daz got to TU did Daz pluck Juice from the JUCO ranks.I like Juice. He's right there with Coyer, passing ability-wise, but I don't think he's as good a runner.Coyer's rushing numbers in some of his junior season games were Bernard Pierce-like.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s